Peppermint vs Rosemary Oil: What Two Scalp Studies Show

Search for peppermint against rosemary on the scalp and you will find the same two studies quoted again and again, often side by side as though they were a fair match. They are not the same kind of study at all. One used mice and the other used people, and knowing that makes it much easier to read what either one can tell you.

Peppermint Essential Oil bottle

Peppermint Essential Oil

Our own Peppermint Essential Oil, in sizes from 0.5 oz to bulk.

From $10.99

Shop Now →

The peppermint study: shaved mice

The peppermint paper, from Oh, Park and Kim in 2014, worked with C57BL/6 mice. Researchers shaved a patch on each animal's back and applied one of four things daily for four weeks: saline, jojoba oil, a 3 percent minoxidil solution, or peppermint oil diluted to 3 percent in jojoba. By the authors' measures, the peppermint group showed the most prominent fur regrowth, along with thicker skin and deeper follicles. The animals' body weight and food intake did not differ between groups.

It is a fun result and it deserves to be read for what it is. A shaved patch on a mouse measures how fast a small area fills back in. It does not describe a human scalp, a human hair cycle or a human dose, and the paper has no way to convert one to the other. Our own arithmetic on the dose: 100 microlitres of a 3 percent solution carries about 3 microlitres of oil, which is roughly a twentieth of a drop at 20 drops to the millilitre. And the 3 percent concentration sits above the 2 percent top of our own skin guidance, so we would not borrow it for a product.

The rosemary study: 100 people

The rosemary trial, from Panahi and colleagues in 2015, is a human study, which makes it the more relevant of the two to everyday life. One hundred people with androgenetic alopecia were randomly assigned to rosemary oil or to 2 percent minoxidil for six months, and photographs taken at the start, at three months and at six months were used to count hairs. Nothing changed significantly at three months. By six months both groups had improved, and the two groups did not differ from each other. Scalp itching rose in both groups and was more frequent with minoxidil.

Here is how we read that. The result is that two treatments ended up looking alike. There was no group that used nothing, so the trial cannot say how much change would have happened anyway. The abstract also does not state the strength of rosemary oil used, so the paper gives you no recipe to follow. It is an interesting trial, and not a verdict on rosemary.

What we do with all this

Our takeaway is a practical one, and it is the same for both oils.

If you just like the scent

There is nothing wrong with choosing peppermint or rosemary for the way it smells in the shower. Peppermint is cool and sweet-minty, and rosemary is herbal and green, and plenty of people simply have a favourite. Pick the one you enjoy, keep the strength low, and let a scented wash day be exactly that.

Whichever you choose, apply a diluted blend with your fingertips, keep it clear of the forehead and eyes, and wash your hands afterward. A scent you like and a routine that stays comfortable are both good reasons to use an oil, and neither one needs a study behind it.

A note on how the oils are described

In the United States a product is judged by what it is intended to do. FDA says a cosmetic is defined by its intended use, and cosmetics do not need premarket approval. That is why we describe our peppermint oils by their aroma and the cooling feel of menthol, and why we describe studies by what they measured. If you would like a wider tour of what the evidence does and does not support, our benefits page sorts it by strength, and the dandruff page covers the other scalp question people ask us about.

For a scalp that simply likes a cool, minty rinse or a diluted massage oil, peppermint is a pleasant companion. For a scalp that worries you, a clinician is the better companion.

One more small point from us: scalp products come off on towels and pillowcases, so a lightly scented, lightly diluted blend is kinder to your linen as well as your skin. Peppermint has a way of making a little feel like a lot, and the best routines we can imagine are the quiet ones, where the scent is a pleasant background and the bottle goes back in the cupboard.

Peppermint Essential Oil bottle

Peppermint Essential Oil

Peppermint Essential Oil from our own shop, in sizes from 0.5 oz to bulk.

From $10.99

Shop Now →

Sources & Further Reading